Fighting Federal Overcriminalization

There are volumes of federal crimes that exist apart from Congress. There are not statutes to reference. They are all deep within federal regulations. And, sadly, many people are committing crimes without ever realizing it.

What is being criminalized?

Petty actions such as riding a dirt bike without taillights in an off-highway vehicle area or making an “unreasonable noise or gesture” at a horse can land you several months in federal prison. Worse, no “mens rea” (meaning, culpable mental state) is attached to these crimes. This means that if you were unaware that your dirt bike had no working taillights, you are still criminally liable.

One might wonder, how is this possible? For decades, federal agencies have wielded the power to create criminal offenses outside of the democratic process, without effective oversight, and to the detriment of thousands of Americans engaged in seemingly innocuous activity.

Is it even Possible to Reverse Course?

Yes, and it is happening in real time. On May 24, 2024, Council to Modernize Governance (CMG) published a proposal urging agencies to audit themselves and remove criminal regulations that potentially imprison unknowing Americans. On May 9, 2025, President Donald J. Trump signed Executive Order 14294, “Fighting Overcriminalization in Federal Regulations.” This Executive Order largely mirrors CMG’s proposal (pages 18–20) by requiring agencies to:

Report on Criminal Regulatory Offenses—Within 365 days of the Executive Order, all agencies, in consultation with the Attorney General, must report all of their respective criminal regulations, their mens rea (i.e. mental state), and their penalties to the Office of Management and Budget;

Independently Publish Their Reports—Agencies must make these reports public and update them at least annually;

Disfavor Referrals for Certain Offenses—Agencies are instructed to disfavor referral for criminal prosecution any offenses that are not listed on their publicized reports and any offenses that do not include a mens rea as an element of the offense;

Ensure Future Regulations Provide Fair Notice—For future regulations, agencies are instructed to explicitly state that the regulation carries criminal penalties, explicitly state a mens rea, and unambiguously cite the act of Congress that permits the agency to issue the regulation;

Publish Enforcement Guidance—Agencies are required to publish guidance before they can refer any criminal regulatory violation to the Department of Justice or otherwise enforce.

To date, most cabinet-level federal agencies with criminal offenses covered by the Executive Order have taken steps consistent with the Executive Order. Many non-cabinet-level federal agencies—such as the Environmental Protection Agency, which has even repealed the problematic regulations—have done the same.

Yet more work can be done. CMG has compiled lists of regulations for both the Department of the Interior and the Department of Agriculture identifying criminal regulations without mens rea, without statutory authorization, or with repealed statutory authorization. These agencies should consider amending or repealing those regulations.

The once-thought-untouchable administrative state has undergone significant reform since CMG’s May 24, 2024, proposal. CMG continues to supplement its work, provide guidance to agencies, and deliver better outcomes for the American people.

Resources

Check out CMG’s proposal and the White House’s initiatives.

CMG Policy Paper: Fighting Federal Overcriminalization

CMG Report: Exposed: Overcriminalization at the Department of the Interior

CMG Report: Exposed: Overcriminalization at the Department of Agriculture

Executive Order #14294: Fighting Overcriminalization in Federal Regulations

CMG Policy Primer: Administrative Overcriminalization